CoolClaret wrote: ↑Thu Aug 10, 2023 1:22 pm
I agree with the shapes/systems and said to my friends earlier in the season when Pep adopted that 3-2-4-1 / 2-3-4-1 in possession that we’ve come full circle from the formations of yesteryear, albeit now just done with more analysis / data.
Give it another few years and there will be a coach rocking a 4-4-2 winning the UCL/WC and that will be the thing back in fashion - heck look at how the Mou made everyone play a 4-3-3 or the German team in 2014 play 4-2-3-1 or Conte bringing wing backs and 3 at the back back to the PL (no one had played three at the back for a good 15+ seasons).
In stark contrast to these new fluid styles is Emery and Villa, ultra ultra organised and rigid with positioning but it works for him and has had success with it - just shows there’s more than one way to skin a cat no matter what’s currently ‘in fashion’.
It happens in the NFL as well things are very circular, one offense will come into fruition then everyone tries it efc till one team has success doing it a different way then everyone tries to copy to keep up / adapt.
For example the NFL is pass heavy now and teams are loading up on receivers/defensive backs… one team will come through and have a tone of success with a heavy old school run game and then that will be the rage again.
With regards to transfers and fees I too err on the side of caution re leveraging loans/all the PL money to try and make big returns on player sales… all I’ll say is that as long as we have Kompany or similar that can develop young players we will be ok - but it is an extremely risky strategy
Agree with all of this and was thinking of Mourinho myself. When he was at Chelsea everyone wanted to play the midfield diamond, when he switched to 433 so did everyone else and it was the 'perfect system'.
In a different vein I think it's something Dyche is underrated on- we didn't play the same 442 tactics/setup the entire time under him. When were in the Championship, both times but especially winning it, we played a very German pressing game before most teams were doing it. When we made Europe, we played what was almost textbook catenaccio but with fast breaking and counterattacking- Arfield sat in the grey zone between a winger and a midfielder in a position I couldn't figure out how to describe until I heard the term mezzala, various players including even Hendrick played the offset forward role slightly behind the main striker.
Formations that look broadly the same under a number system can be very different in practice, just like how tactics that are hard to categorise numerically, like Guardiola's, become easier to understand when you look at historical tactics.
Everything's in cycles and with the rise of Haaland, we're already seeing teams start to move back to the idea of a big centre forward, ideally one with an all round game too but basically a rounded target man. Can definitely see either 451, or the classic big man little man 442 coming back in vogue- if a team had Haaland and Mbappe or any 2 of Haaland/Kane/Lewandowski/Hojlund I'd fully expect them to go 442.