Harry McGuire and James Tarkowski

[Cooclaret]

They’re the same player.

[Milltown1882]

Maguire *

[4midable]

Tarkys better for sure

[RVclaret]

Pope is better than both

[Rowls]

Everton have conceded joint second least goals this season. What's changed for them, I wonder?

Manchester United conceded the same amount of goals (six) in the two games Maguire started for them this season.

[Spiral]

Tarky handsomer that Maguire. We're doing naff all at the WC anyway, so we might as well get some homoerotic arousal out of it all. Amarite, lads?

Lads?

[boatshed bill]

They’re the same player.

Dinosaur defenders?

[COBBLE]

After tonight. Harry Maguire the gift that keeps on giving. Giving the ball away, giving penalties and giving enough space away for the opposition to take control. Tarks even when he thinks he is Rio Ferdinand is a safer bet.

[Belgianclaret]

I’d love Maguire to play for Blackburn

[conyoviejo]

Maguires not fit to lace Tarkys boots.

[IanMcL]

Maguire end tonight. Carthorse exposed.

[dermotdermot]

Tarky handsomer that Maguire. We're doing naff all at the WC anyway, so we might as well get some homoerotic arousal out of it all. Amarite, lads?

Lads?

EVERYONE is more handsome than Maguire. He must be frightened of mirrors.

[Cooclaret]

Maguire end tonight. Carthorse exposed.

Absolutely, he’s a poor Tarks and Tarks isn’t close to being good enough to play for England.

[jdrobbo]

Everton have conceded joint second least goals this season. What's changed for them, I wonder?

Manchester United conceded the same amount of goals (six) in the two games Maguire started for them this season.

Agree with this but also feel Conor Coady deserves a mention too.

[Rowls]

Agree with this but also feel Conor Coady deserves a mention too.

Certainly.

I don’t watch enough of the other teams to know if Tarky (or Coady) should be in the squad but I’ve seen enough of Maguire to know that he shouldn’t be.

[Hipper]

What's happened to McGuire?

Highly thought of at Sheff Utd and Hull; did well at Leicester; then Man Utd.......

[IanMcL]

What's happened to McGuire?

Highly thought of at Sheff Utd and Hull; did well at Leicester; then Man Utd.......

His ability is in the air. His frailty in his cumbersome shape and speed, on groundwork. His penalty giveaway was just slowness. He can head very well and pass ok but is easily caught out, around the box.

[jrgbfc]

A fresh start away from Man United would probably do Maguire a lot of good now.

[Vegas Claret]

McGuire would have been great in the 1990's